Programming Using Objects
Objects - Basics
Of the two OOP implementations FPC provides, the one used less often seems to be what is referred to as "Objects" which probably gets its name from the type definition syntax. The syntax diagram for an object type declaration can be found in the FPC language reference - Chapter 5. Basically, an object type looks like a record type with additional fields including procedure fields and also optional keywords which indicate the scope of the fields. In fact, an oversimplified (but valid) simple object is hard to distinguish from a record structure as can be seen below.
Type MyObject = Object f_Integer : integer; f_String : ansiString; f_Array : array [1.3] of char; end;
The only difference in the above example is that the Pascal keyword record has been replaced with the keyword object. Things start to be different when methods are added to the object. Object methods are declared in FPC using the keywords procedure or function. These object methods (procedures or functions) are declared the same way as normal Pascal procedures and functions; just that they are declared within the object declaration itself. Lets create a different object; this time possibly as part of an oversimplified graphics drawing program.
Type DrawingObject = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure Draw; end; Var Rectangle : DrawingObject;
Besides the simple datatype fields providing some application specific location and size attributes, the object shown above declares an additional parameter; a procedure called Draw. The type declaration is followed by a variable identifier called Rectangle of the type DrawingObject. Next, the Draw procedural code itself needs to be written as well as well as code for accessing and manipulating the data fields, as well as how to invoke the Draw procedure. The following simple program shows how all this works. It should compile and run on any system with FPC 2.2.2 and above. Note: For Mac OS X, the -macpas compiler directive must be turned off.
Program TestObjects; Type DrawingObject = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure Draw; // procedure declared in here end; procedure DrawingObject .Draw; begin writeln('Drawing an Object'); writeln(' x = ', x, ' y = ', y); // object fields writeln(' width = ', width); writeln(' height = ', height); writeln; // moveto (x, y); // probably would need to include a platform dependent drawing unit to do actual drawing // ... more code to actually draw a shape on the screen using the other parameters end; Var Rectangle : DrawingObject; begin Rectangle.x:= 50; // the fields specific to the variable "Rectangle" Rectangle.y:= 100; Rectangle.width:= 60; Rectangle.height:= 40; writeln('x = ', Rectangle.x); Rectangle.Draw; // Calling the method (procedure) with Rectangle do // With works the same way even with the method (procedure) field begin x:= 75; Draw; end; end.
As can be seen in the above program, the body of the Draw method (procedure) is declared after the object type declaration by concatenating the type identifier with the procedure name. In a more realistic situation, the object would likely be declared in the interface section of a separate unit while the procedure body would be written in the implementation section of the same external unit. In this example, only standard vanilla Pascal is used, but if actual graphic primitives are available, they can be used if desired. The second thing to notice is that inside the Draw method (procedure), the object's data fields are referenced as if they were regular local variables. The only difference to regular local variables is that the values of these fields will persist between calls to the Draw procedure.
In the main program, the fields are assigned values and accessed just like record fields are. Similarly, the Draw procedure is invoked using the same dot notation as the fields. And like records, the with keyword works the same for accessing object fields and invoking methods. Finally, notice that the second time the Draw method is called, all the fields persisted between calls; the only field different is the x attribute which was explicitly changed.
The above example is meant to show the basic mechanics of simple Objects. There are a couple of problems, however. The first problem is that the Draw method only draws one thing and that is a rectangle (although even that is questionable.) Additional methods could be declared in the DrawingObject object such as DrawRectangle, DrawCircle, DrawTriangle, etc..., but this would not be too much different than declaring separate regular procedures and having to use case statements to select the appropriate procedure. So doing it this way with objects would require more work (and is not how it is accomplished.) The other problem is, the object's fields are able to be accessed and modified anywhere in the program very similar to using global variables which makes it harder to write well encapsulated and robust programs. These problems will be addressed in the next section.
Objects - Static Inheritance
Next, the code will be expanded to specifically handle rectangles and squares. Other shapes could be handled as well in a similar manner. An attempt will be made to leverage the existing code, if possible, by creating two new objects to handle the two specific shapes. In order to make the code and output easier to follow, the main object type, DrawingObject has been renamed TShape. Other object types will be named TRectangle, TSquare, and TTriangle with corresponding variables named Shape, Rectangle, Square and Triangle. The letter "T" is used as a prefix to the object type names since it is a commonly used convention in many object libraries and frameworks including FPC's.
What follows are type declarations for: the main TShape object type (previously DrawingObject) along with the new types TRectangle and TSquare. TShape now includes a new method (procedure GetParams) to obtain values for its fields. Next, the types TRectangle and TSquare are declared. TShape is usually referred to as an ancestor or parent object, while TRectangle is said to be a child or subobject or subclass of TShape or that it descends from TShape. This parent, child, grandchild hierarchy is identified by the qualifier type name following the Object keyword. Similarly, TSquare is a child of TRectangle. Also, TShape is not really a complete object type in itself but rather a template for other objects to inherit a common structure and behavior(s) from. Such templates are often useful for code clarity and there are language features (explained later) which can be used to enforce certain characteristics of these template objects. For an actual application, the TShape type would more than likely be declared differently. Here it is used to illustrate some basic concepts.
Type TShape = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure GetParams; procedure Draw; end; TRectangle = Object(TShape) procedure Draw; end; TSquare = Object(TRectangle) procedure GetParams; procedure Draw; end; Var Shape : TShape; Rectangle : TRectangle; Square : TSquare;
Notice that TRectangle lists only the Draw procedure while TSquare lists both the GetParams and Draw procedures. Neither of the subobject types include any fields. The "missing" fields and missing procedure names are said to be inherited from the fields and procedures declared in ancestor objects. In this case, any object variables declared and instantiated of type TRectangle will inherit from the TShape type all four fields, (x, y, height, and width) and the GetParams method . At runtine, a variable of the type TRectangle will look and behave like a TShape variable except that the Draw procedure will use different code than the procedure by the same name in an instantiated variable of the TShape type. Similarly, the TSquare object type will inherit all the "grandparent" fields from TShape and have its own different procedure blocks. If desired, TRectangle and TSquare could have declared additional fields in their type definitions which would show up as additional fields (memory locations) available at runtime which instantiated parent object variables would not have or be able to access.
Next are the specific procedure implementations for these object types.
procedure TShape.GetParams; begin write('TShape.GetParams : '); readln(x, y, width, height); writeln; end; procedure TShape.Draw; begin writeln('TShape.Draw'); writeln('Position: x = ', x:4:0, ' y = ', y:4:0); writeln(' Size: w = ', width:4:0, ' h = ', height:4:0); writeln; end; procedure TRectangle.Draw; begin writeln('TRectangle.Draw'); end; procedure TSquare.GetParams; begin write('TSquare.GetParams : '); readln(x, y, width, height); height := width; writeln('making sure all sides are equal for Square'); writeln; end; procedure TSquare.Draw; begin writeln('TSquare.Draw'); end;
To provide clarity, no actual (platform specific) drawing routines are used. Rather, generic Pascal I/O routines are included to illustrate runtime behavior. This particular hierarchy of objects, fields and methods would likely not be the best implementation for an actual shape drawing application which will become more apparent after new concepts are introduced.
The GetParams method is used to obtain and to perform any needed processing of the field values. Although the object fields could be accessed directly as was done in the previous section, it is considered better programming style to encapsulate the "getting" a "setting" of object fields using object methods. In fact, FPC provides additional language features to help support and enforce narrowing the accessibility and visibility of internal object data which will be covered later.
Since the different types of objects in this program all use the same fields, using a common GetParams method would seem to make sense to include at the top level ancestor object which all other descendent objects can inherit/use. Thus, this method is implemented in the TShape object type.
The TShape object type includes a second method, Draw, which is probably not needed in an actual shape drawing program since it is not a defined shapre. However, a variable declared of type TShape likely will be assigned to a variable of a descendent object type such as TRectangle, which does need to have a draw method which will draw using the code of the descendent object type. Normally, this "template" method would just be declared as a stub or not implemented at all. The syntax for this type of situation and others will be described later. In this case, we want to provide some feedback to inspect field values and illustrate program flow so for demonstration purposes, it includes some writeln statements.
The TRectangle object type does not include a GetParams method but does have its own Draw method. The TSquare object type has it's own GetParams method which repeats much of the the same code from the TShape.GetParams method but also adds code to ensure that the height and width fields are the same. TSquare defines its own Draw method. In an actual program, the Draw method for squares and rectangles would probably be the same and the Draw method for TSquare could be omitted and just inherited from TRectangle.
Here is a sample program which demonstrates the behavior of the various objects.
Var Shape : TShape; Rectangle : TRectangle; Square : TSquare; begin writeln; writeln ('Getting parameters for Shape'); Shape.GetParams; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Getting parameters for Rectangle'); Rectangle.GetParams; write ('Calling Rectangle.Draw : '); Rectangle.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Getting parameters for Square'); Square.GetParams; write ('Calling Square.Draw : '); Square.Draw;
The above code produces the following output.
Getting parameters for Shape TShape.GetParams : 1 2 3 4 Calling Shape.Draw : TShape.Draw Position: x = 1 y = 2 Size: w = 3 h = 4 Getting parameters for Rectangle TShape.GetParams : 11 22 33 44 Calling Rectangle.Draw : TRectangle.Draw Getting parameters for Square TSquare.GetParams : 111 222 333 444 making sure all sides are equal for Square Calling Square.Draw : TSquare.Draw
Tthe Shape object is initialized by calling the GetParams method and then the Draw method is called which prints out the field values. Next, the same is done for the Rectangle object. Notice that since there is no GetParams method for Rectangles, the compiler used the parent object's method, TShape.GetParams to carry out this action. Finally, the Square object is initialized by calling the GetParams method which is explicitly defined for Squares and the output shows this method was called and did extra processing. The Draw method is called and the Draw method specifically defined for Squares was executed. Note that if the Draw procedure was left out for the TSquare type (as would be reasonable for an actual program) the last output line would look like this.
Calling Square.Draw : TRectangle.Draw
Now what happens if we assign a sub object variable to a parent variable as follows?
writeln; writeln ('Assigning Rectangle to Shape'); Shape := Rectangle; writeln; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Assigning Square to Shape'); Shape := Square; writeln; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Assigning Square to Rectangle'); Rectangle := Square; writeln; write ('Calling Rectangle.Draw : '); Rectangle.Draw;
The following is output.
Assigning Rectangle to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TShape.Draw Position: x = 11 y = 22 Size: w = 33 h = 44 Assigning Square to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TShape.Draw Position: x = 111 y = 222 Size: w = 333 h = 333 Assigning Square to Rectangle Calling Rectangle.Draw : TRectangle.Draw
The first block of code assigns the Rectangle variable to the Shape variable. When the Shape.Draw method is invoked, it executes the TShape.Draw code and not the TRectangle.Draw code. But as can be seen, the Rectangle fields is what are printed out. This behavior is called Static method inheritance in FPC. If it is desired to instead invoke the child TRectangle.Draw method in this situation, FPC provides way to do this called virtual methods which will be covered in the next section. Continuing on, Shape is assigned to Square and the TShape.Draw method is invoked which prints out the field values of the Square object. Finally, the Rectangle variable is assigned the Square and the TRectangle.Draw method is invoked similarly to the behavior of the TShape.Draw methods.
Assigning an ancestor object to a descendent object is not allowed. The compiler will flag the following line as an error.
Rectangle := Shape; <--- can't assign a parent to a child, does not compile
Objects - Virtual Inheritance
For a drawing application, a common task would be to refresh the display and stepping through an array or linked list of shapes and calling the draw method. Instead of needing a case statement inside the loop which selects one of many possible specific drawing procedures
for k := 1 to NumShapes do with ShapeRec[k] do case ShapeRec[k].ShapeKind of cRectangle : DrawRectangle (x, y, width, .height); cSquare: DrawSquare : (x, y, width, .height); cTriangle: DrawTriangle:(x, y, angle1, angle2, base); end; // case
the code would look something like this
for k:= 1 to Numshapes do Shape[k].draw;
Where each Shape object could be one of any sub objects descended from TShape. Code maintenance is made easier since there is one fewer locations in code which needs to be modified. All changes to the behavior of a particular sub object of shape is kept together in one place.
However, as seen in the last section, calling the Draw method for the Shape variable this way will not invoke the appropriate draw method of the sub object which is the behavior that is desired in this (and most) cases. To obtain the desired behavior, the virtual keyword must be inserted after the method declaration in the type definition as follows:
Type TShape = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure GetParams; procedure Draw; virtual; end; TRectangle = Object(TShape) procedure Draw; virtual; end;
Now if a Rectangle object is assigned to the Shape variable, the Draw method of TRectangle will be used. The term often used to describe this situation is called overriding a parent method. Although the body of main program will the same as in the previous section, the execution behavior will be different. The virtual keyword tells the compiler to hold off fixing the specific procedure used and instead lets the binding of the method be determined at runtime dynamically.
By adding the virtual keyword to the type declarations of TShape, TRectangle and TSquare in the last section, the latter portion of the output would look as shown below. Note that in order to run the previous program using virtual methods, some other code needs to be added in order for the program to run. This additional code is described in the next section.
Assigning Rectangle to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TRectangle.Draw Assigning Square to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TSquare.Draw Assigning Square to Rectangle Calling Rectangle.Draw : TSquare.Draw
Although it is allowed, mixing virtual methods and non virtual (static) methods in the inheritance hierarchy may result in behavior which is difficult to manage.
Objects - Constructors and Destructors
Compiling the above example program after adding the virtual keywords will result in non fatal compiler warnings about missing constructors. Although the warnings can be ignored, a run time error will almost certainly occur when one of the virtual Draw methods is executed. Due to the peculiarities of this particular OOP implementation, when virtual methods are declared, special initialization code must be included for that object. Specifically, two specialized methods must be included in the object type definition called a constructor and a destructor. The constructor must be called at runtime to initialize the object's virtual method before the method is called. In addition, the constructor can be (and should) be used to initialize any fields, dynamically create associated objects and any other initialization tasks needed when introducing an object. The special destructor method is used to take care of any internal and program specific housekeeping when an object is no longer needed. The initialization and cleanup tasks are more useful when using dynamically allocated objects which will be covered in this section also. For simple programs with few objects (like the one in this tutorial), calling not using destructors won't cause any problems. However, in large programs and those that use large class libraries which routinely allocate and deallocate objects dynamically, the implementation of constructors and destructors is very useful.
Here are are the Shape declarations again, this time using virtual methods and including constructors and destructors.
Type TShape = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure GetParams; virtual; procedure Draw; virtual; Constructor Init(xx, yy, h, w : single); Destructor CleanUp; end; TRectangle = Object(TShape) procedure Draw; virtual; end; TSquare = Object(TRectangle) procedure GetParams; virtual; Constructor Init(xx, yy, h, w : single); end;
The TShape object type includes fields, two virtual methods (Draw and GetParams), a constructor called Init and a destructor called CleunUp.
TRectangle declares its own Draw method which will override the Parent method in TShape but will inherit all other fields, methods, and the constructor and destructor from TShape.
TSquare inherits everything from its ancestors (TShape mostly) except for the GetPArams method and the Init constructor.
In declaring a constructor or destructor, the keyword constructor or destructor is used instead of the keyword function or procedure. In all other respects, they look just like object methods and are called just like object methods. The use of the constructor/destructor keyword is to let the compiler know of any behind the scenes actions to take. Also notice, that the Init constructor includes a parameter list. Normal methods can include parameter lists although none have been used in the tutorial up to this point.
Fields, methods, constructors and destructors can be declared in any order in the type definition.
Constructors and destructors act like virtual methods without having to add the virtual keyword.
For the current program, the Draw method for TSquare has been removed. It will be assumed that the (fictional) graphics code for for drawing a square is the same as for a rectangle and the Draw method can be inherited from TRectangle. The difference in the TSquare and TRectangle object is inherent in the Init constructor and GetParams method. Implementation of the new constructors and destructors is shown below.
Constructor TShape.Init(xx, yy, h, w : single); begin writeln('TShape.Init'); x := xx; y := yy; height := h; width := w; end; Destructor TShape.CleanUp; begin writeln('TShape.CleanUp') end; Constructor TSquare.Init(xx, yy, h, w : single); begin writeln('TSquare.Init'); x := xx; y := yy; height := h; width := w; if height <> width then height := width; end;
Again, the implentation of constructors look like regular methods except the keywords constructor and destructor are used instead of the keywords procedure and function. Consider the following main program.
begin writeln; Shape.Init(1,2,3,4); Rectangle.Init(11, 22, 33, 44); Square.Init(111, 222, 333, 444); writeln; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; write ('Calling Rectangle.Draw : '); Rectangle.Draw; write ('Calling Square.Draw : '); Square.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Assigning Rectangle to Shape'); Shape := Rectangle; writeln; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Assigning Square to Shape'); Shape := Square; writeln; write ('Calling Shape.Draw : '); Shape.Draw; writeln; writeln ('Assigning Square to Rectangle'); Rectangle := Square; writeln; write ('Calling Rectangle.Draw : '); Rectangle.Draw; writeln; Shape.CleanUp; Rectangle.CleanUp; Square.CleanUp; end.
which produces the output below.
TShape.Init TShape.Init TSquare.Init Calling Shape.Draw : TShape.Draw Position: x = 1 y = 2 Size: w = 4 h = 3 Calling Rectangle.Draw : TRectangle.Draw Calling Square.Draw : TSquare.Draw Assigning Rectangle to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TRectangle.Draw Assigning Square to Shape Calling Shape.Draw : TSquare.Draw Assigning Square to Rectangle Calling Rectangle.Draw : TSquare.Draw TShape.CleanUp TShape.CleanUp TShape.CleanUp
Notice that all three calls to the destructor CleanUp result in the using the inherited destructor of TShape since TRectangle and TSquare did not override the CleanUp constructor. The virtual Draw method was overridden for each sub object type and the output reflects this even when the sub objects were assigned to the parent object. Finally, since none of the sub objects implemented destructors, all calls to the CleanUp destructors used the one declared for the parent TShape object. If any of the destructors were declared separately in a sub object, they would have overridden the destructor for TShape since all constructors and destructors are virtual by default.
FPC allows any procedure identifier to be used for a constructor or destructor name. However, by convention, many OOP languages and object libraries use specific identifiers. One convention is Create for constructors and Destroy for destructors.
Objects - Dynamic Variables
Although static object variables can be created on the stack as has been shown up to this point, it is much more likely that for most programs, objects will be created dynamically. The syntax for declaring dynamic objects and invoking them are similar to that of any other dynamically created variable. The only difference is the addition of an extended syntax for the New keyword which incorporates invoking the object constructor.
Here, pointer types and variables are declared for the various object types defined previously with some sample code snippets showing how the resulting dynamic variables are created, manipulated and disposed. Only the object declaration for TShape is shown and none of the methods, constructors or destructors. Note that in order to inspect the field values more easily, the Draw method was reverted back to static so the TShape.Draw behavior was available for all the different types of objects.
The first thing to notice that there are three different ways to create dynamic object variables. All three produce the same results. All use the new procedure in different ways. The Shape1 and Shape2 objects are being created using new as a function, passing it two parameters: (1) the type name and (2) the name of the Init constructor and returning a pointer to the object. The second way is using new as a procedure with the desired variable (Rectangle in this case) to be to be created and the constructor name as parameters. Finally, a pointer for the Square object is created with the new procedure and then the constructor method is called separately. This last manner of dynamic object creation will generate a compiler warning but will compile and run OK.
Next some assignments with objects are made and the Draw method to see how the objects were affected. As can be seen, the results of the assignment operations differ depending whether or not the assignments were done with the pointer variables themselves or whether the pointer was dereferenced. The results are the same for manipulating and dereferencing pointers to objects just as they are for any other type of data structure. Finally, the dispose procedure is called for all the created objects. Just as there are three ways to use the new procedure, there are three ways to use the dispose procedure. All three ways are shown.
Type TShape = Object x, y : single; height, width : single; procedure GetParams; virtual; procedure Draw; Constructor Init(xx, yy, h, w : single); Destructor CleanUp; end; PShape = ^TShape; PRectangle = ^TRectangle; PSquare = ^TSquare; Var Shape1, Shape2 : PShape; Rectangle : PRectangle; Square : PSquare; begin Shape1 := new (PShape, Init(1, 1, 1, 1) ); Shape2 := new (PShape, Init(2, 2, 2, 2) ); new (Rectangle, Init(11, 22, 33, 44) ); new(Square); Square^.Init(111, 222, 333, 444); writeln; Write ('1) Shape1 : '); Shape1^.Draw; Shape1^ := Rectangle^; Write ('2) Shape1 : '); Shape1^.Draw; Rectangle^.x := 77; Write ('3) Shape1 : '); Shape1^.Draw; Write ('4) Shape2 : '); Shape2^.Draw; Shape2 := Square; Write ('5) Shape2 : '); Shape2^.Draw; Square^.y := 88; Write ('6) Shape2 : '); Shape2^.Draw; writeln; dispose(Shape1); dispose(Shape2, CleanUp); Rectangle^.CleanUp; dispose(Rectangle); dispose(Square, CleanUp); end.
TShape.Init TShape.Init TShape.Init TSquare.Init 1) Shape1 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 1 y = 1 Size: w = 1 h = 1 2) Shape1 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 11 y = 22 Size: w = 44 h = 33 3) Shape1 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 11 y = 22 Size: w = 44 h = 33 4) Shape2 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 2 y = 2 Size: w = 2 h = 2 5) Shape2 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 111 y = 222 Size: w = 444 h = 444 6) Shape2 : TShape.Draw Position: x = 111 y = 88 Size: w = 444 h = 444 TShape.CleanUp TShape.CleanUp TShape.CleanUp